I recently read Premka, White bird in a Golden Cage: My life with Yogi Bhajan by Pamela Dyson, January 2020. I quote from the book’s blurb: a compelling and beautifully unfolding tale, offering a haunting look into a teacher/student relationship. This intimate memoir, written by one of Yogi Bhajan’s prized teachers and exalted students, is full of devotion, love, dedication, betrayal, loss and the healing unification of the self. It also reads as a love letter to a unique time in history—the ‘60s in Los Angeles and New Mexico, where love, music, art, spiritual exploration, often led to self-transformation. As a historical treatise and a spiritual mystery, this book offers unique insight into the origins of the Western Sikh movement and the proliferation of Yogi Bhajan’s kundalini yoga.
My personal response
I was deeply moved by Pamela’s story, and shocked and saddened to hear about the abuse, exploitation, hypocrisy, conflict, manipulation and confusion all carried out by the hand of Yogi Bhajan, the beloved teacher and founder of Kundalini Yoga as taught by Yogi Bhajan. It threw me and yet did not surprise me, he was among many leaders of different schools of yoga, and spiritual and religious traditions who abused his position of power and devotion and behaved in a way that is in absolute contrast to his teachings. But I am quite naive and never thought this applied to our own teacher, mainly because as a second generation teacher, I have met a few teachers and yogis who have worked and studied with and for Yogi Bhajan, and I have only ever heard devotion and love expressed for him. I look forward to hearing from teachers and the Kundalini Yoga Teacher’s Association at the beginning of our annual festival this year.
As teachers we were taught that Yogi Bhajan was a man of great compassion and humility. We were invited to watch many videos of his teachings and have a picture of him on our shrines and to practice a meditation which involved gazing into his eyes in a photograph. So I suppose for a teacher who has not met him (indeed I have felt little or no connection to him throughout my years as a teacher, something which has caused me to doubt myself often), there is not so much a personal sense of betrayal, but a curiosity about the community that upheld him as someone we should channel and live up to – did people know about his abuses of power and keep it secret? I am sure many did not, some may have been victims and some were keeping things quiet or turning a blind eye. This is the power of spiritual devotion and dedication. And the power of the fear of being cast out from his family, which is what allegedly happened to anyone who challenged his behaviour or wanted to leave the fold. I can only imagine the emotional confusion.
I think I have much more to understand and I need more information. And I need to practice forgiveness and release. My teachers and Yogi Bhajan are all flawed human beings – (I have a tendency to idolise all teachers). And of course there are many aspects to ones’ character and a flawed human being can also have many gifts and wisdom to share. Shadows and light. I do not doubt his remarkable ability to put together a technology that creates such powerful transformation and self-realisation, regardless of his limitations as a human being. I also believe that his teachings have a long lineage in many traditions of yoga and the vast majority of yogis are pure, loving and good.
And I am ever grateful to my own teachers for their part in my personal and professional growth. My year studying and teaching with Tonnie and Hanneke in Cambodia was possibly the most formative year of my life. It do not think it is any coincidence that they neither used their spiritual names, wore turbans and they were Buddhist. I think this meant that I could relate to them and the strange new teachings culturally and emotionally – to be practicing and preaching Sikhism in Cambodia would have felt strange. (To be clear, the teachings are not about Sikhism, but Yogi Bhajan was a Sikh and many of his teachers practice Sikhism.) So my first teachers were much more about bringing the beauty of these teachings to people and places who needed to heal, than spreading any kind of movement or doctrine.
How does this affect me as a teacher and what I continue to teach?
I will always love teaching Kundalini Yoga! It remains the most powerful tool for overall health and healing and transformation that I have ever practiced. I just love how holistic it is, what strength it brings and what great shape it keeps us in, physical, mental and spiritual! Every day that I practice I only fall in love with them more. That one man’s weaknesses and failings should destroy a whole school of beautiful life-changing teachings is unthinkable to me. However, this revelation does cause me discomfort and confusion – and it also reinforces my own desire to bring a pure loving energy into every class I hold. A few things I have reflected on:
The privilege of a teacher comes with responsibility
Firstly this has reminded me of my own responsibility to my students. The teacher trainings were always rather sketchy when it came to the therapeutic relationship and I am forever grateful that I had a foundation in counselling and that I did my Kundalini Yoga training alongside a wonderful Arts Therapy course that upheld the ethics and responsibility of the therapeutic relationship at the heart of its teachings. I understand the dynamic of student/teacher/therapist better and better each year that I practice, and also from my own experiences in therapy. But one’s own insecurity means that it can often not sink in that it applies to me as a teacher. Until I see that a room full of students will sit and chant with their arms in the air for as long as you ask them to, just because you say it is a good idea! It is a great position of privilege and power to be a teacher, and I am reminded to always ensure that my teachings are coming from a place of purity, spirit, heart, goodwill, informed practice and humility.
The teacher is not the teachings… but the teacher is part of the relationship (we were taught the first bit only!)
Secondly, this has taught me to trust in my own instincts and my own way of teaching. To trust in the responses of my yoga students who show me each week how what I offer helps them and uplifts them. That it is okay to be myself when I teach, not simply a product of a doctrine. That my desire to make it as accessible as possible rather than to promote any kind of lineage is a good thing. I was told by my teacher Hanneke, “You will never wear a turban”. When I think that I teach hundreds of children every month and many many adults over the years – I think she was right. My purpose was to make it accessible to all.
Years ago I was told off by a wise older student for never accepting his words of gratitude but always brushing them aside in saying “Its the teachings, not me!” He pointed out that he was grateful to me and me refusing to accept that love and gratitude was not very elevated as a teacher (and also very annoying!) We were taught to remove ourselves before we teach – I know this is important in that we can’t let our own agenda or needs get in the way of the teachings (ironic given what we now know about the source of some of the teachings) – but in teaching self-love, we also need to be open to acknowledging our own unique gifts as teachers and show others how to receive gratitude with an open heart, not with our ego that brushes it away (or soars high. Both happen and both are normal.)
I have also been challenged by another student, and fellow Kundalini Yoga Teacher, for not teaching the teachings alone, but also bringing in my other influences such as wisdom and healing I have gained through the years through spiritual healing, art therapy, meditation, pagan/nature/animism, mindfulness and life. The implication was that a teacher who did this was not to be trusted, as they were bringing too much of themselves into their teachings. This is the power of indoctrination – that we should believe that there is only one road to enlightenment, that we have to stick to the rules of one tradition only… when sharing all that has served me and helped me along the way has always been my passion and my calling – indeed that is why I trained to teach Kundalini Yoga – it healed and helped me so much, it changed my life.
Now I see that all the years where I questioned my devotion to the teachings because I did not want to wear a turban, use the spiritual name given to me, or do a full 2.5 hours of yoga before dawn after a night of breastfeeding and day ahead of school runs and teaching and motherhood were not all down to my ego overpowering my soul after all. They were years of me listening to my own body, mind and soul – something that I believe passionately is the answer to inner peace, and so much a part of the journey of true emancipation of women, and yet something that it seems Yogi Bhajan wanted to take away from the men and women in his community.
Intuitively I have taught the teachings that have served me well, never changing them as I would not know how or where to begin, but set amidst my own concoction of pure, loving teachings and experiences from my life so far. I have drawn on the wisdom of many teachers and spiritual leaders over the years, when these teachings have helped and supported me. And I believe that teaching in a way that welcomes all paths and traditions stimulates creativity in the teacher and students, is a path of growth and freedom for all, a path that empowers and encourages self-healing and exploration. After all, so many of my students are way ahead of me on the road to Enlightenment and have so much wisdom to share and they can and do bring that into class. Actually Yogi Bhajan did teach us that our students are always 11 x more enlightened than we are – so he was right regarding himself as well, in that respect. He offers us a gift to rise above his short-comings and bravely shine a light on our own shadows.
So my invitation to you is to keep taking from the teachings all that serves you, don’t be afraid to question them or me – hold me to account always! Although you know I often don’t have the answers. And be intuitive, brave and creative in your own journey towards the light. Please ask me anything you need to, via phone, zoom or email or in person when we are allowed to meet again.
With love and gratitude always to you all and to Pamela Dyson for bravely sharing her story and those women who are also finding the strength to speak up, in this case and all over the world.
Georgie